Problem redefinition paper

Hi everyone. We are a group of lecturers learning about TRIZ, we have stuck in a concept names “Problem Redefinition” from CREAX software. The reason to write in thie blog is to know if anyone knows about a paper or reference which might help us to clarify this concept?

Thanks in advanced

Adrian

Advertisements

5 thoughts on “Problem redefinition paper

  1. Dear Prakash, we are focusing on the CREAX way of Problem redefinition. I will take a look to journal-triz.

    Thanks for your answer.

    Best regards

  2. Dear Adrian,

    I think if you are looking for CREAX way of problem reformulation – the best place is to ask CREAX (http://www.creax.com).

    Very similar, if not the same, problem formulation process has been kindly shared by Darrell Mann’s Systematic-innovation website http://www.systematic-innovation.com/download/download.htm

    I am little curious to know – what is it that you guys are Stuck at. May be we can help you get unstuck 🙂

    Look forward to hearing the “conceptual stuck”.

    with warm regards
    Navneet
    navneet.bhushan@crafitti.com

  3. Dear Navneet, that´s right the Creax way of problem reformulation is where we are stuck. We are a group of lecturers who are meeting every Friday to learn more about the different tools of TRIZ, the problem we have is that we might have used a wrong problem and started to dream. Trying to find the evolution for a wheelchair, someone said that the problem should be stated as “To provide movement to a handicapped person” and trying to narrow and broaden the problem many strange things started to appear. I felt we lost ourselves in the definition of the problem. That is our situation. Could you help us? Thanks in advanced.

    All the best

  4. Dear Adrian,
    I am sorry for such a late reply, things have kept me busy.

    My learning while exploring the problem space is to explore it in as many strange ways and with as many different ways before reaching to the interesting set of problems through a convergence process. Looks like we do not spend much time in exploring the problem space. One point I can suggest is explore both the narrowing and broadening using the “why-what stops” recursive hierarchy. Also apply the nine screen/nine windows to the problem, get a large number of associated problems by the use of all the tools – without evaluating – where we are going. Just keep on expanding, broadening, narrowing so that you really characterize the scenarios/problems/situations in ways that open gives a holistic understanding.
    Then the convergence happens towards key problems, one of the ways is to look at what are the key contradictions – because the subsystems evolve at different rates, contradictions are part of every system. However, there are 8 laws and the cardinal law of moving towards ideal system where the function is achieved with minimum resources and no adverse effects on the system.

    So in nutshell – please start with functions – which I think was nicely formulated as to provide movement to a handicapped person. May be starting with 9 windows first may help. Nevertheless – please dont feel about strange things – they are best whenever you start defining and exploring the space. I think it was Einstein who said,” If an idea at first doesnt appear absurd, it has no hope”.

  5. We (few members within this group) are teaching TRIZ to Engineering and Business colleges including couple of IIT’s in South India. All these are free courses that we do, starting 2 hours a week as an elective non credit courses, and sometime a 2 days TRIZ workshop. Feel free to let us know If you would like any colleges to utilize this free services.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s